Friday, December 9, 2011

Metamorphosis - The Lost Generation - Dying Alone


The Metamorphosis - Franz Kafka                                                November 23, 2011
Gregory isolation and depression are similar to that which Paul Bäumer experiences in All Quiet on the Western Front.  Bäumer and Gregory both experience drastic changes in their lives.  Bäumer comes home on leave and the horrors of war have destroyed his ability to relate to people but also any joy he can take in life.  Gregory’s transformation has completely isolated him from his family.  The death of both these young men is tragic.  Both men die isolated and alone.
The death of Gregory at the end of Metamorphosis is more tragic because His family is almost relieved by it. “Since the cleaning woman seemed to have once more disturbed the peace of mind they had just barely attained.”  Gregory’s death gives the family the peace it has been looking for.  The first thing they choose to do is to take a stroll out of town into the country.  “. . .they discussed their prospect for the future, and proved that, on closer examination, theses were not at all bad, . . .were thoroughly advantageous and particularly promising for later on.” Gregory sacrifice is taken for granted, there is no eulogy, no memorial for him. 
Kafka uses the contrast between the dead Gregory and the new realized beauty of his sister to speak to Gregory’s isolation. The Samsas realize that their daughter: “had blossomed out into a beautiful, well-built girl . . . . They though it was now time to find a good husband for her.” This stands in contrast to the denial to Gregory’s longing for companionship.  For Kafka the human experience is much like that of the soldiers coming home from the war.  This experience is full of hardship and sacrifice, most importantly is experienced alone and when finished the life of those around it role on and continue as if it had not existed.
Forrest Gaffney, PHC Junior, 2013

Beckett's Need for Community


Waiting for Godot – Samuel Beckett                                             December 5, 2011
            Aristotle said that man is by his nature a political animal.  In Genesis, God declared it is not good for man to be alone.  In the second act of Waiting for Godot, Estragon declares imperatively: “Don’t touch me! Don’t question me! Don’t speak to me! Stay with Me!” [Becket, 63] Beckett’s play makes a multileveled attack on the absurdity of human existence, but one “positive” theme is that people find comfort in community.  Both Vladimir and Estragon fear being left alone.
            Pozzo after being help up by the two, also make an imperative statement.  “Don’t question me! The Blind have no notion of Time.  The things of time are hidden from them too.” [Becket, 99]  Like Pozzo, Estragon suffers from this blindness to time, and Vladimir may well be on the way to going blind.  Without time there can be not transcendence, this blindness would cause all experience to become sensory.  Pozzo, Vladimir, and Estragon have lost transcendent connection in their lives. 
While Vladimir hopes to find meaning through Godot, It is obvious, Beckett believes this waiting is futile, time passes and nothing happens.  I believe that Becket might be still clinging to this need for community.  There are not lone Byronic heroes in Godot’s play.  While humanity is clawing blindly for meaning, he sometimes finds comfort in companionship.  In the case of Pozzo and Lucky companionship is exploitive and painful.  With Vladimir and Estragon companionship is painful but sometime comforting.  In both cases neither choose to live without it. 
Forrest Gaffney, PHC Junior, 2013

The Irony of Prayer & Kattrin, Beauty from a Marxist perspective


Bertolt Brecht – Mother Courage – Journal Entry - November 30, 2011
The Peasants Son in scene eleven, is forced to guide a Catholic regiment to ambush the town.  Bewailing the fate of the city, The Peasant woman asks: “There is nothing we can do, is there?” They know if they warn the city, that they will pay for it with their lives.  The peasant woman concludes: “No, there’s nothing we can do. (to Kattrin) Pray, poor thing, pray! . . .So even if you can’t talk, at least pray!  He hears, if no one else does.”  This is the first time in Mother Courage, that we see any genuine form of religious expression that is not directly mocked by people on stage.
Brecht, a Marxist, chose to show an earnest form of religious expression.  It is interesting that even this heartfelt act could be used to satire religion.  From a moral standpoint the peasants are using their ability to pray in the place of actually to do what is right.  In this case the peasants religion has paralyzed them from acting.  The simple Kattrine however is not subject to such hypocrisy.  Earlier in the work Mother courage described Kattrin as “being crazy for children.”  Kattrin groans through the prayer, it is when there is danger to the children that she is motivated to make her act of self-sacrifice to warn the town.
In class we questioned Brecht’s use of Kattrin as a Christ figure.  How can Brecht the Marxist paint such a beautiful and noble picture?  I believe it was not accidental.  It is a significant that Kattrin “the picture of Christ” is executed by “Christian” soldiers.  It is possible that Marxists can admire Christ as a historical figure but the reject the message of his church.  Marxist would do this by separating the message from the messenger. As true believers we find it impossible to separate Christ's beauty from the His truth.  The Marxist could admire beauty of Kattrin’s sacrifice, but fail to find the truth behind it. 

Forrest Gaffney, PHC Junior, 2013