Thursday, September 27, 2012

Frankenstein's Suicide



This week we read the end of Frankenstein, and Frankenstein’s monster promised to commit suicide in the frozen north.  Last week, I thought about whether or not the monster had a soul, and I concluded that it didn’t have a soul.  So, was the monster’s promised suicide a good thing he did, or was it murder against himself like suicide is for humans?  Since humans have a soul and the monster did not, that line of argument can not be used. 
The only possible way to reconcile the monster to our world is through animals.  So, if animals could think, would it permissible for them to commit suicide?  I only know of one instance where an animal could have allegedly committed suicide, and that was at a professional baseball game where the bird flew right in front of a pitch and went poof.  Animals don’t have souls, and we do euthanize our pets and animals frequently.  Just over a year ago, we euthanized our cat because she had intestinal problems and she was in pain. 
Killing a live animal is tough for humans because we value life.  We know we must eat, but it still takes some time to get used to killing animals.  So, because it is ok to eat meat, from animals that we kill, it is permissible for men to kill animals for food.  But the first glaring problem is that Frankenstein’s monster was not created for food, he was created to be a thinking creature.  So, if he were to die, it could not be for food purposes. 
The other scenario where men kill animals is when the animal kills or maims a man or woman, and the Bible backs this up in the Old Testament law.  So, because the monster had killed men and women, both directly and indirectly, it is was permissible for him to be murdered, so it doesn’t really matter if he killed himself because he was fulfilling the justice of this world. 

Saturday, September 22, 2012

Friendship and Balance:



Mary Shelley seems an ardent apologist for friendship in Frankenstein. One specific portrayal of friendship in the work yields a unique glimpse into Shelley’s views of an ideal friendship.
            In the second opening letter in Frankenstein, Robert Walton complains,

I bitterly feel the want of a friend. I have no one near me, gentle yet courageous, possessed of a cultivated as well as of a capricious mind, whose tastes are like my own, to approve or amend my plans….I greatly need a friend who would have sense enough not to despise me as a romantic, and affection enough for me to endeavor  to regulate my mind.

As with other parts of Walton’s letters, this passage draws out a theme to be pursued for the rest of the book. Here, the theme is the use of a friend to balance out one’s temperament. Walton seeks someone who does not disapprove of, but will counterbalance Walton’s own romantic tendencies—someone who can evaluate Walton’s plans and honestly critiques them.
            This concept of balancing through friendship next appears within the main portion of the book, this time exemplified by Victor Frankenstein and Elizabeth Lavenza. Victor says, “Harmony was the soul of our companionship.” The word chosen to describe the essence of the friendship is “harmony”, the combination of unlike things to create a beautiful unity. Victor’s narrative goes on to describe the differences between him and Elizabeth: her calmness and his ardor, her contentedness and his curiosity. These differences were what created the aforementioned harmony.
            And then the duet admitted a third: Henry Clerval. Henry’s poetic romanticism tempered Victor’s romantic empiricism. At the same time, “the saintly soul of Elizabeth shone like a shrine-dedicated lamp in our peaceful home.” Victor describes how Elizabeth’s virtues softened his own harsher elements and inspired Henry’s noble ambitions. At each point, one of the friend’s virtues covers over another’s vice.
            Then comes Victor’s departure for Ingolstadt. Here, Victor is alone, left to his own devices. And, presently, he becomes unbalanced. This is where Victor commits his sins: alone in his laboratory away from “friends who were so many miles absent, and whom I had not seen for so long a time.” Without the checks of Henry and Elizabeth, Victor descends into obsession. The part of his character which before now had always been balanced expands without opposition. And it creates a monster.
            As portrayed in Frankenstein, an integral part of friendship is the harmonious resistance one temperament puts on another. Friends compensate for each other’s weakness. Someone without this benefit becomes a slave to his own shortcomings. Is not that what happens to Frankenstein’s monster? Cut off from all friendship, he embraces his inhuman nature and truly becomes a monster. Friendship is the force that counteracts such evils. Thus, friendship becomes vital. As Justine says in her last words to Elizabeth, “Live, and be happy, and make others so.” To bring true, lasting happiness into lives through the balancing power of friendship, that is the high calling advocated by Frankenstein. And it is not an ignoble calling.

Josiah Duran, Sophomore

Transcendent Monsters


We were passing through the asteroid belts in the outer reaches of Katorsis Fourteen when we detected the distress signal. A small escape pod, floating helplessly in space. Honestly, I was surprised, as was my entire crew, to find any sign of human life in this unexplored system. We were on a ship on an exploratory mission, traveling far beyond the depths of known space—were we not the first?
We immediately drew alongside the pod and drew it into our hangar bay. My first lieutenant and myself, drawn by curiosity, were there when my men unsealed the pod.
There was only a single occupant inside the pod, but as my men hastened to assist him from it, he held out his hand. “Where,” he asked, “is this ship bound?”
“We are explorers,” I answered. “I am the captain of this ship, and it is destined to the Katorsis System on a voyage of scientific discovery.”
At this response, he appeared satisfied, and allowed my men to help him depart the escape craft. He was emancipated from lack of food, and the stale, frigid air inside his cramped pod told me his life support systems were failing, and that in a matter of days—no, hours, he would have succumbed to asphyxiation and unbearable cold. Indeed, his knees buckled and he collapsed as soon as he stood. My men brought him into the medical bay and revived him; as soon as he became sensible, they fed him some soup and put him to rest.
When he awoke the next morning, I was on hand to question him. What, I asked him, was he doing in this God-forsaken system?
His countenance immediately assumed an aspect of the deepest gloom; and he replied, “To seek one who fled from me.”

I think that, in most cases, the best stories are ones that transcend setting. For instance, sci-fi stories or action adventure novels that rely entirely on their setting to make them interesting or attractive to modern readers may be enjoyable and even good or original, but they suffer from a definite flaw: relevance over time. Truly transcendent stories, on the other hand, remain relevant no matter how much time passes. That is why we still read Homer today, because his books deal with themes that transcend his immediate boundaries of time and space. Indeed, this is probably why his works survived to the present day: because something in them resonated with his readers.
It is not too hard to find what themes resonate with people. Love, hatred, honor, strife, peace, struggles and conflicts—humans thrive on these types of stories. At its base, a good story is good because it is true, but it is also good because its subject matter is human. Much has changed since Homer’s day, but human nature still remains the same, and we can analyze and dissect his characters because they are like us.
This, I believe, is one of the reasons Frankenstein remains such an enduring work. The book sparking something in man—something savvy writers refer to as the “Frankenstein Complex,” a phrase coined by writer Isaac Asimov. Asimov used it to refer to human fear of robots, but more broadly, it can be applied to an idea of a creature destroying its creator, of humankind’s inventions turning on him to destroy him.
And yet, most of us have no experience with our creations coming to life and destroying them. Certainly there have been instances of this throughout history—men betray their masters, countries their leaders. But the Frankenstein Complex does not seem as accessible to men as things we experience everyday. We have all experienced love and hate, strife and conflict. Our own creatures coming to life and attacking us? Not so much. Perhaps we are looking in the wrong place. Perhaps the appeal of Frankenstein is not because we relate to Frankenstein.
Perhaps we are the monsters.

Frankenstein bears something in common with an earlier work of great literature, Paradise Lost. Both books center around a creature’s rebellion against its creator. But Paradise Lost remains a distinctively Christian work of literature because it is about the rebellion of God’s creations against Him. Ultimately, one of His creations—man—goes so far in their rebellion as to kill their Creator.
Perhaps, then, this is the appeal of Frankenstein; the idea that transcends Mary Shelley’s brief span upon this earth—the idea that mankind is an ungrateful creature that has rebelled against its Creator. While few of us have been tormented by creations of our own design, mankind as a whole lives with the uneasy feeling that we are, deep inside, monsters cut off from our Creator. This idea of disunity with the Creator resounds throughout religions worldwide, and one only has to look through the pages of history to see humans morph into monsters. As I attempted to briefly illustrate in the opening paragraphs, the core of Frankenstein is a story that transcends time, and it is able to do so because it is about a story that is eternal: an ungrateful creature, lost from its Creator, trapped in sin, and wanting a way out.

Derringer Dick, Sophomore 

Saturday, September 1, 2012

Familiar Spirits


Much to my initial surprise, Gulliver’s Travels, continues into a third part after Gulliver’s visit to Brobdingnag. In this third part, the protagonist has the opportunity to visit a variety of astounding lands, including one island ruled by a necromancer. This necromancer, who entertained Gulliver during his stay on the island, conjured the dead to be his domestics. Upon first seeing these undead servants, Gulliver experienced “horror I cannot express.” But, a few pages later, Gulliver says, “I soon grew so familiarized to the sight of spirits, that after the third or fourth time they gave me no emotion at all: or, if I had any apprehensions left, my curiosity prevailed over them.”
            This passage does not seem particularly odd upon a first glance. But, when one stops to think what Gulliver actually says, it becomes quite striking: Gulliver adjusts to seeing the dead walk. This adjustment occurred, Gulliver says, after only experiencing the undead three or four times. Jonathan Swift seems to think highly of humanities ability to accept the fantastic. And, indeed, there is some truth to this portrayal. Swift lived in an age when new inventions, never before conceived, were rocking Western civilization. Many began to see anything as possible, and would have likely, upon seeing a demonstration of necromancy, begun devising practical applications.
            More importantly, however, Swift portrays a fundamental trait of human nature: the ability to take anything for granted. On the one hand, the ability to converse with the dead is a remarkable thing. People let the remarkable become familiar all too often. In one sense, Swift reminds readers not to despise the amazing opportunities within their reach.
            On the other hand, necromancy is evil. Mankind possesses special skill at becoming desensitized to evil. And once evil becomes innocuous, it never fails to carry the day. Through the brief mention of the spectral servants, Swift demonstrates that one can become desensitized to something in a very short space. In a way, this topic dominates the entirety of Gulliver’s Travels. From when Gulliver struggles to readjust to England after Brobdingnag, until the last part of the book where the author reminds of the many injustices accepted by virtually everyone, Swift shows his readers how easily they’ve fallen into the trap and how desensitized they have become.
            As the platitude states, the first step towards cure is acknowledgement. By emphasizing the human ability to be unfazed by good and evil, Swift sets his audience on the road to remediation. Swift would have people admire good and recoil from evil. And so, in this passage on the wraith domestics, he gives the exhortation to lose sight of neither.

Josiah Duran, Sophomore