Questions to Help You Analyze and Evaluate Literature
(taken from Literature: Structure, Sound and Sense by Laurence Perrine)
Fiction
Plot:
- Who is the protagonist of the story? What are the conflicts? Are they physical, intellectual, moral, or emotional? Is the main conflict between sharply differentiated good and evil, or is it more subtle and complex?
- Does the plot have unity? Are all the episodes relevant to the total meaning or effect of the story? Does each incident grow logically out of the preceding incident and lead naturally to the next? Is the ending happy, unhappy, or indeterminate? Is it fairly achieved?
- What use does the story make of chance and coincidence? Are these occurrences used to initiate, to complicate, or to resolve the story? How improbable are they?
- How is suspense created in the story? Is the interest confined to “What happens next?” or are larger concerns involved? Can you find examples of mystery? of dilemma?
- What use does the story make of surprise? Are the surprises achieved fairly? Do they serve a significant purpose? Do they divert the reader’s attention from weaknesses in the story?
- To what extent is this a “formula story”?
Characters:
7. What means does the author use to reveal character? Are the characters sufficiently dramatized? What use is made of character contrasts?
- Are the characters consistent in their actions? Adequately motivated? Plausible? Does the author successfully avoid stock characters?
- Is each character fully enough developed to justify his role in the story? Are the main characters round or flat?
- Is any of the characters a developing character? If so, is his change a large or a small one? Is it a plausible change for him? Is it sufficiently motivated? Is it given sufficient time?
Theme:
- Does the story have a theme? What is it? Is it implicit or explicit?
- Does the theme reinforce or oppose popular notions of life? Does it furnish a new insight or refresh or deepen an old one?
Point of view:
13. What point of view does the story use? Is it consistent in its use of this point of view? If shifts are made, are they justified?
- What advantages has the chosen point of view? Does it furnish any clues as to the purpose of the story?
- If the point of view is that of one of the characters, does this character have any limitations that affect his interpretation of events or persons?
- Does the author use point of view primarily to reveal or conceal? Does he ever unfairly withhold important information known to the focal character?
Symbol and Irony:
17. Does the story make use of symbols? If so, do the symbols carry or merely reinforce the meaning of the story?
- Does the story anywhere utilize irony of situation? Dramatic irony? Verbal irony? What functions do the ironies serve?
Emotion and Humor:
- Does the story aim directly at an emotional effect, or is emotion merely its natural by-product?
- Is the emotion sufficiently dramatized? Is the author anywhere guilty of sentimentality?
Fantasy:
21. Does the story employ fantasy? If so, what is the initial assumption? Does the story operate logically from this assumption?
- Is the fantasy employed for its own sake or to express some human truth? If the latter, what truth?
General:
23. Is the primary interest of the story in plot, character, theme, or some other element?
- What contribution to the story is made by its setting? Is the particular setting essential, or could the story have happened anywhere?
- What are the characteristics of the author’s style? Are they appropriate to the nature of the story?
- What light is thrown on the story by its title?
- Do all elements of the story work together to support a central purpose? Is any part irrelevant or inappropriate?
- What do you conceive to be the story’s central purpose? How fully has it achieved that purpose?
- Does the story offer chiefly escape or interpretation? How significant is the story’s purpose?
- Does the story gain or lose on a second reading?
Poetry
1. Who is the speaker? What kind of person is he?
2. To whom is he speaking? What kind of person is he?
3. What is the occasion?
4. What is the setting in time (time of day, season, century, etc.)?
5. What is the setting in place (indoors or out, city or country, nation, etc.)?
6. What is the central purpose of the poem?
7. State the central idea or theme of the poem is a sentence.
8. Discuss the tone of the poem. How is it achieved?
9a. Outline the poem so as to show its structure and development, or b. Summarize the events of the poem.
10. Paraphrase the poem.
11. Discuss the diction of the poem. Point out words that are particularly well chosen and explain why.
12. Discuss the imagery of the poem. What kinds of imagery are used?
13. Point out examples of metaphor, simile, personification, and metonymy and explain their appropriateness.
14. Point out and explain any symbols. If the poem is allegorical, explain the allegory.
15. Point out and explain examples of paradox, overstatement, understatement, and irony. What is their function?
16. Point out and explain any allusions. What is their function?
17. Point out significant examples of sound repetition and explain their function.
18a.What is the meter of the poem? b. Copy the poem and mark its scansion.
19. Discuss the adaptation of sound to sense.
20. Describe the form or pattern of the poem.
21. Criticize and evaluate the poem.
Drama
(The fiction and poetry questions above also apply to drama. The following questions are additional and specific to the genre.)
1. Does the play employ realistic or nonrealistic conventions? On the spectrum from literalistic imitation of reality to stylized or surrealistic representation, where is the play situated? Are there breaks from the conventions established as a norm in the play? If so, what is the dramatic effect of these departures? Are they meaningful?
2. Is the play a tragedy or comedy, a melodrama or a farce? If a comedy, is it primarily romantic or satiric? Does it mingle aspects of these types of drama? How important to experiencing the drama is the audience’s awareness of the classification of the play?
3. Identify the protagonist(s) and antagonist(s). Are there any foil characters? What dramatic functions are served by the various minor characters? Do they shed light on the actions or motives of the major characters? Do they advance the plot by eliciting actions by others? Do they embody ideas or feelings that illuminate the major characters or the movement of the plot?
4. How is dramatic suspense created? Contrast the amount of information possessed by the audience as the play proceeds with the knowledge that various individual characters have: what is the effect of such a contrast?
5. What themes does the play present? To what extent do the thematic materials of the play have an effect on the dramatic experience? Does the power of the ideas increase or decrease the pleasure of the theatrical experience? Does the play seem either too didactic or insufficient in its presentation of important human concerns?
6. How do the various physical effects – theatrical components such as sets, lights, costuming, makeup, gestures, stage movements, musical effects of song or dance, and so forth – reinforce the meanings and contribute to the emotional effects? By what means does the playwright indicate the nature of these physical effects – explicitly, through stage directions and set descriptions, or implicitly, through dialogue between characters?
7. What amount of time is covered in the action? How much of the action is presented as a report rather than dramatized on stage? Is there a meaning behind the selection of events to be dramatized and those to be reported? Does the play feel loose or tight in its construction? Is that feeling appropriate to the themes and dramatic effects of the play?
8. To what extent does the play employ narration as a means of dramatic exposition? What other expository methods does it use? Does the exposition have a function beyond communicating information about prior events? What effects on the audience do the expository methods have?