Aristophanes' Clouds
Peter D. Arnott edition
TRUE LOGIC: “What makes you so smart?”
FALSE LOGIC: “Me? I’m an original!”
FALSE LOGIC: “Me? I’m an original!”
False Logic’s jaunty retort to True Logic’s indignant interrogation underscores an important question about the nature of sin. Is sin (false logic) something new, something innovative, something original? Aristophanes seems to think so. According to the dialogue between True and False Logic, True Logic represents the ways of the past, while False Logic, in the words of the Chorus, is a “destroyer of tradition” who must “utter something sharp and novel.”
From a Christian perspective, though, is it proper to consider unrighteousness as “original”? Perhaps; the word “original” has many meanings. For example, “original” can mean “first,” and in theology, “original sin” refers to the sin that dominates the first stage of our lives, from our first breath until our second birth. However, “original” can also mean “new and without precedent,” and in this sense “original” does not accurately describe sin. Something that is “new and without precedent” must be its own distinct entity, complete with creative flourishes bestowed upon it by its maker. Sin, however, is not its own distinct entity; it is the absence of righteousness, the perversion of all things good, a cheap knock-off. In this sense, then, it is not False Logic but True Logic who is the true original. False Logic holds no new, heretofore forbidden delights that True Logic cannot offer; rather, all False Logic can offer are tepid substitutes for True Logic’s exhilarating draft.
In Clouds, however, True Logic neither seems original nor wins the argument. In Aristophanes’ world of polytheistic religion, True Logic loses its claim to originality—its origin in the eternally infinite goodness of God—and becomes a mere preference based on the same moral foundation as False Logic, i.e. the capriciously corrupt gods. Aristophanes was a prescient, imaginative thinker, but original sin blinded him to the reality that, in fact, True Logic is truly original.
Harrison Otis - Freshman, 2015
Good Job Harrison, The search to be original is very prevalent in today's culture. Yet it is true, God is the original in Him is the everlasting light that has been from the beginning of time.
ReplyDelete