Friday, March 2, 2012

The Slaying of Turnus


            “Tis Pallas, Pallas gives this deadly blow.” Thus said Aeneas as he drove his sword into Turnus, ending the life of his enemy. It has been said that Aeneas was wrong to kill Turnus—that he should have instead given mercy to the fallen hero. Those who hold to this position say that revenge is not a proper motive for killing, especially when the vanquished has begged for mercy. And, to be sure, they are correct in that assertion. Thus the critical issue is centered on the motive. If Aeneas was motivated by revenge, then the killing of Turnus would be wrong. However, I believe there is another motive at play, one that makes the slaying justified. That motive is justice.
            Justice is retribution given to a person for a crime committed. So, in order to establish the criterion for justice in Turnus’ death, we must first look back to an earlier time—the slaying of Pallas. While killing Pallas outright was perhaps justified due to the war occurring, it is immediately apparent that Turnus committed an egregious sin against his foe. Turnus had two options. First, he could have extended mercy to Pallas—the same mercy he later desired. Second, Turnus could have killed Pallas swiftly and cleanly, which is the proper thing to do in war. However, Pallas did neither. Instead, he placed his foot on Pallas’ dyeing body and shouted an insult to the father of Pallas. Then, he ripped off Pallas’ belt and wore it himself as a war trophy. Granted, such actions were common in war. But recurrence does not make an action right or good. Rape is often committed in war—but rape is still evil. The actions of Turnus were wrong under the same criteria.
            Now that it is established that Turnus committed a wrong, it is easier to examine the events surrounding Turnus’ death. When Aeneas had defeated Turnus, he was prepared to give him mercy. Interestingly, that was the same mercy that Turnus had earlier denied to Pallas. However, there was a greater issue at play. Aeneas realized that Turnus was not only the slayer of Pallas but was also proud enough of his deed to flaunt Pallas’ belt as a trophy. To Aeneas, this became an issue of justice, which is revealed by his words: “Traitor, dost thou, dost thou to grace pretend/Clad as thou art, in trophies of my friend?” The issue is that Turnus had asked for mercy—but had given no quarter. He had thus become a traitor to the laws of war in the mind of Aeneas. Thus, in justice Aeneas killed Turnus.
            It may be said that killing Turnus was still revenge, though perhaps slightly justified. Rage was still an issue for Aeneas. True, Aeneas was wrathful. However, his words are telling, for he said that he did not strike the blow, but rather Pallas did. The retribution came not from a feud on the part of Aeneas, but from the necessity of repaying the evil done. There are several biblical precedents for this action. The first is where God told Cain that the blood of Abel cried out to the Lord against Cain. The second is the lex talensis beginning with the Noahic Covenant and continuing throughout the legal code of the Bible. Crime deserves punishment. Aeneas was fulfilling that just cause by slaying Turnus, the malefactor.

Christopher Hamilton, Freshman

No comments:

Post a Comment