Thursday, September 27, 2012

Frankenstein's Suicide



This week we read the end of Frankenstein, and Frankenstein’s monster promised to commit suicide in the frozen north.  Last week, I thought about whether or not the monster had a soul, and I concluded that it didn’t have a soul.  So, was the monster’s promised suicide a good thing he did, or was it murder against himself like suicide is for humans?  Since humans have a soul and the monster did not, that line of argument can not be used. 
The only possible way to reconcile the monster to our world is through animals.  So, if animals could think, would it permissible for them to commit suicide?  I only know of one instance where an animal could have allegedly committed suicide, and that was at a professional baseball game where the bird flew right in front of a pitch and went poof.  Animals don’t have souls, and we do euthanize our pets and animals frequently.  Just over a year ago, we euthanized our cat because she had intestinal problems and she was in pain. 
Killing a live animal is tough for humans because we value life.  We know we must eat, but it still takes some time to get used to killing animals.  So, because it is ok to eat meat, from animals that we kill, it is permissible for men to kill animals for food.  But the first glaring problem is that Frankenstein’s monster was not created for food, he was created to be a thinking creature.  So, if he were to die, it could not be for food purposes. 
The other scenario where men kill animals is when the animal kills or maims a man or woman, and the Bible backs this up in the Old Testament law.  So, because the monster had killed men and women, both directly and indirectly, it is was permissible for him to be murdered, so it doesn’t really matter if he killed himself because he was fulfilling the justice of this world. 

2 comments:

  1. I'd never thought of the monster's story in terms of an animal committing suicide--probably partly because I'd never read the end of Frankenstein until two days ago. But as soon as you mentioned it, I thought of the classic novel Where the Red Fern Grows. The dog Little Ann doesn't exactly commit an act of suicide after Old Dan is killed in the fight with the mountain lion, but she does lose her will to live and dies a few days afterwards. Similar or different?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very interesting line of thought, Mackey. A lot to contemplate.

    ReplyDelete