Mary Shelley seems an ardent apologist for
friendship in Frankenstein. One
specific portrayal of friendship in the work yields a unique glimpse into
Shelley’s views of an ideal friendship.
In
the second opening letter in Frankenstein,
Robert Walton complains,
I bitterly feel the
want of a friend. I have no one near me, gentle yet courageous, possessed of a
cultivated as well as of a capricious mind, whose tastes are like my own, to
approve or amend my plans….I greatly need a friend who would have sense enough
not to despise me as a romantic, and affection enough for me to endeavor to regulate my mind.
As with other parts of Walton’s letters, this
passage draws out a theme to be pursued for the rest of the book. Here, the theme
is the use of a friend to balance out one’s temperament. Walton seeks someone
who does not disapprove of, but will counterbalance Walton’s own romantic
tendencies—someone who can evaluate Walton’s plans and honestly critiques them.
This
concept of balancing through friendship next appears within the main portion of
the book, this time exemplified by Victor Frankenstein and Elizabeth Lavenza.
Victor says, “Harmony was the soul of our companionship.” The word chosen to
describe the essence of the friendship is “harmony”, the combination of unlike
things to create a beautiful unity. Victor’s narrative goes on to describe the
differences between him and Elizabeth: her calmness and his ardor, her
contentedness and his curiosity. These differences were what created the
aforementioned harmony.
And
then the duet admitted a third: Henry Clerval. Henry’s poetic romanticism
tempered Victor’s romantic empiricism. At the same time, “the saintly soul of
Elizabeth shone like a shrine-dedicated lamp in our peaceful home.” Victor
describes how Elizabeth’s virtues softened his own harsher elements and
inspired Henry’s noble ambitions. At each point, one of the friend’s virtues
covers over another’s vice.
Then
comes Victor’s departure for Ingolstadt. Here, Victor is alone, left to his own
devices. And, presently, he becomes unbalanced. This is where Victor commits
his sins: alone in his laboratory away from “friends who were so many miles
absent, and whom I had not seen for so long a time.” Without the checks of
Henry and Elizabeth, Victor descends into obsession. The part of his character
which before now had always been balanced expands without opposition. And it
creates a monster.
As
portrayed in Frankenstein, an
integral part of friendship is the harmonious resistance one temperament puts
on another. Friends compensate for each other’s weakness. Someone without this
benefit becomes a slave to his own shortcomings. Is not that what happens to
Frankenstein’s monster? Cut off from all friendship, he embraces his inhuman
nature and truly becomes a monster. Friendship is the force that counteracts
such evils. Thus, friendship becomes vital. As Justine says in her last words
to Elizabeth, “Live, and be happy, and make others so.” To bring true, lasting
happiness into lives through the balancing power of friendship, that is the
high calling advocated by Frankenstein.
And it is not an ignoble calling.
Josiah Duran, Sophomore
I appreciated your post, Josiah! I hadn't seen that part of the book in that way before. I would add that although friendship is a necessary and noble calling, it is transitory and not the end of life.
ReplyDeleteVictor's fall demonstrates not only the value of friendship but also of personal character. All of Victor's character was bound up in his friends, so when he left them behind he left his character behind as well. The same thing happens today, I think, with kids who grow up in Christian homes, go off to a secular school, and abandon their parents' faith. Their belief was never belief at all; it was a parasite living off the friendships & influence of the people around it. Thus, although friendship is vitally important, it is not--and cannot be--redemptive. Redemption from our vices is not a community effort. It can only happen on the individual level through the saving work of Jesus Christ.
You're quite right Harrison in cautioning against seeing friendship as redemptive. I do think, however, that Shelley does think of it as redemptive. That's why my post comes across that way, I'm largely laying out the view from the book.
DeleteNice job, Josiah. The bit about harmony reminded me of Plato, and I thought you did a good job of tying the creation of the monster to his separation from his friends. How do you think things would have turned out if he had confided in his friends instead of hiding the truth about his monster from them?
ReplyDeleteI don't know what would have happened if he had confined in his friends after he already made that monster (although, at very least they could have been on their guard so as to not get killed). But I think they would have dissuaded him from the initial experiment altogether if he had made them privy.
DeleteI dunno...would your friends dissuade you from creating a monster? :D
Delete